Ariel Flinn - Electronic Portfolio
  • Introduction
  • Video Reflection
  • Résumé
  • Vision
  • Diversity
  • Standards
    • Standard 1 >
      • 1.1 Shared Vision
      • 1.2 Strategic Planning
      • 1.3 Policies, Procedures, Programs & Funding
      • 1.4 Diffusion of Innovations & Change
    • Standard 2 >
      • 2.1 Content Standards & Student Technology Standards
      • 2.2 Research-Based Learner-Centered Strategies
      • 2.3 Authentic Learning
      • 2.4 Higher Order Thinking Skills
      • 2.5 Differentiation
      • 2.6 Instructional Design
      • 2.7 Assessment
      • 2.8 Data Analysis
    • Standard 3 >
      • 3.1 Classroom Management & Collaborative Learning
      • 3.2 Managing Digital Tools and Resources
      • 3.3 Online & Blended Learning
      • 3.4 Adaptive and Assistive Technology
      • 3.5 Basic Troubleshooting
      • 3.6 Selecting and Evaluating Digital Tools & Resources
      • 3.7 Communication & Collaboration
    • Standard 4 >
      • 4.1 Digital Equity
      • 4.2 Safe, Healthy, Legal & Ethical Use
      • 4.3 Diversity, Cultural Understanding & Global Awareness
    • Standard 5 >
      • 5.1 Needs Assessment
      • 5.2 Professional Learning
      • 5.3 Program Evaluation
    • Standard 6 >
      • 6.1 Continuous Learning
      • 6.2 Reflection
      • 6.3 Field Experiences
  • Field Experiences
  • Blog
  • Capstone

Student Blogging

1/25/2014

4 Comments

 
As I discussed in a previous post, blogs have the power to connect writers, in this case the students, with a worldwide audience and community through the magic of commenting, linking, and the nature of reading to write. Richardson (2010) lists several different ways to incorporate blogging into the classroom, such as using blogs for students to connect with a classroom across the world, express their own opinions about a class discussion, describe class activities and their reaction to those activities, conduct a survey about their learning, respond to writing prompts, and many more (pp. 39-40). Blogs can also be used as Web-based portfolios, in which the students take ownership of their own material and learning and track their progress over the course of a month, a semester, a school year, or several years. 

There are clearly many ways to incorporate blogs into student learning. But, how should a teacher assess student writing in a blog? Julie Meloni brings up a good point in this blog post: because blogs are supposed to be informal, how can we use them to assess student writing objectively, for example on a 5-point scale? If students do use blogs for formal writing, are they really still blogs, or just a replacement for pencil-and-paper essay writing? If we assess them on completion, then what exactly are the criteria for completion? These are all questions a teacher must answer for him or herself before diving into the world of student blogging. 

One way to objectively grade any performance-based assignment, e.g., writing, is through the use of a rubric. Not all rubrics are created equally! What works for the purposes of one class does not necessarily work for another. For example, a blogging rubric for an English/Language Arts Class would probably look different than one for my Music class, simply because we would be assessing different standards. An ELA teacher might put a heavier weight of the grade on things like grammar, punctuation, and spelling. While I would include these things in my rubric, I would not weigh them as heavily in the overall grade. That said, there should be some common themes for assessing student blogging. For example, Mark Sample created a 5-point scale for assessing critical thinking in blog posts. I think this is a great example of an aspect of blogging that can be assessed in any subject or any grade level, because the whole point of student blogging is to get them thinking critically about their learning. He goes on to say that the rubric should have transparency: the students should know and understand how they are being graded.

The University of Wisconsin, Stout's rubric covers many different areas, including the blogginess of blogging. Did the student consider her audience? Did she use timestamps and tags to chronicle and categorize her post? Is she posting often or infrequently? Did she include links to other websites? Did she include graphics and multimedia elements? Did she use proper citations for all her linked and referenced material? I think these are all important aspects for consideration. If students are not using blogs as real blogs with all that they offer, then why have them use blogs at all? Including these elements in the rubric assures that the students will not only learn to utilize these features of blogs, but also know how to execute them well. 

Because the commenting feature of blogs is one of the most unique and influential aspects of blogging, students should also learn how to construct meaningful and collaborative comments on others' blogs in order to gain the full experience of blogging. Kathleen Morris goes so far as to say students should learn how to comment before learning how to create their own posts. She suggests a process in which students begin by practicing with comments on teacher-written posts, followed by assisting the teacher in writing posts, creating their own posts on the teacher/class blog, and finally creating and authoring their own blogs; all the while, students continue to practice quality commenting. This rubric does a great job outlining what exactly constitutes quality commenting. 

After viewing these sample rubrics, I created my own rubric to asses student blogging in my classroom. It includes blogginess elements as well as critical thinking both in the student's original post and in comments on others' posts. I also weighted each category based on what I thought was most important. 

Franker, K. (2012, January 17). A rubric for evaluating student blogs. Uwstout.edu. Retrieved January 25, 2014 from https://www2.uwstout.edu/content/profdev/rubrics/blogrubric.html

Meloni, J. (2009, August 13). Integrating, evaluating, and managing blogging in the classroom [Web log post]. Retrieved January 23, 2014, from http://chronicle.com/blogs/profhacker/integrating-evaluatingmanaging-blogging-in-the-classroom/22626

Morris, K. (2012, January 15). Setting up student blogs [Web log post]. Retrieved January 25, 2014, from http://primarytech.global2.vic.edu.au/2012/01/15/setting-up-student-blogs-2/

Richardson, W. (2010). Blogs, wikis, podcasts, and other powerful Web tools for classrooms. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Publishers.

Sample, M. (2010, September 27). A rubric for evaluating student blogs [Web log post]. Retrieved January 23, 2014, from http://chronicle.com/blogs/profhacker/a-rubric-for-evaluating-student-blogs/27196#

Tolisano, S. (2011, December). Commenting rubric. Langwitches.org. Retrieved January 25, 2014 from 
http://langwitches.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/commenting-rubric.jpg

Utecht, J. (2010, June). Blogs as web-based portfolios. Thethinkingstick.com. Retrieved January 22, 2014 from http://www.thethinkingstick.com/images/2010/06/Blogs-as-Web-Based-Portfolios.pdf 
4 Comments
Chris Stepenson link
1/26/2014 04:30:39

I love the ideas that in-class activities, which become owned by students’, also, become a track to their progress over a year. As you rightly point out, however, how do we use these to assess student writing objectively (especially as a music or a geography teacher!)
You interestingly talk about Julie Meloni’s ideas around blogging and the criteria for completion of a blog post for assessment purposes. I wrestled with that idea too – after all a blog is personal writing that is responding and building on knowledge. I’m not sure from your post if you looked at one of the links from her site: Hillary Millar’s “Lessons from a First-Time Course Blogger”. In that post, Millar talks about the block eliciting “strong work” which, on the whole, should be rewarded somewhere in the grade that the student receives in the class. From the rubric that you posted, it allowed the student to be creative but still keep straight all the criteria for good writing that needs to be contemplated when producing a professional blog.
I’m a middle / high school teacher and wonder how you manage to get the littler ones in Elementary School to really engage in this kind of activity?

Thought provoking post for sure!

Reply
Karen Artis
1/31/2014 09:06:31

Your thoughts on blogs being added to web based portfolios really made me start exploring ideas. Portfolio becomes more enriched with a blog added. It makes you wonder just how long resumes will still be need when an employer is trying to inquire about you. The blog give a 3D perspective allowing the individual behind the portfolio to be more transparent. To extend that thought a little further how about college applications? Often times Universities are trying to get a well-rounded perspective. It would not surprise me that if in the future portfolio will be a requirement from grade k-12. What better way to track and collect information and provides a well rounded perspective.
You also commented that blogs are supposed to be informal, but after all the research and reading blogs can be classified as whatever the intention of the author is. The expectation of writing guidelines can be applied. It’s a perfect example of how to make a tool more specified for your need as a teacher.

Reply
Karen Artis
1/31/2014 09:06:54

Your thoughts on blogs being added to web based portfolios really made me start exploring ideas. Portfolio becomes more enriched with a blog added. It makes you wonder just how long resumes will still be need when an employer is trying to inquire about you. The blog give a 3D perspective allowing the individual behind the portfolio to be more transparent. To extend that thought a little further how about college applications? Often times Universities are trying to get a well-rounded perspective. It would not surprise me that if in the future portfolio will be a requirement from grade k-12. What better way to track and collect information and provides a well rounded perspective.
You also commented that blogs are supposed to be informal, but after all the research and reading blogs can be classified as whatever the intention of the author is. The expectation of writing guidelines can be applied. It’s a perfect example of how to make a tool more specified for your need as a teacher.

Reply
Karen Artis
1/31/2014 09:07:18

Your thoughts on blogs being added to web based portfolios really made me start exploring ideas. Portfolio becomes more enriched with a blog added. It makes you wonder just how long resumes will still be need when an employer is trying to inquire about you. The blog give a 3D perspective allowing the individual behind the portfolio to be more transparent. To extend that thought a little further how about college applications? Often times Universities are trying to get a well-rounded perspective. It would not surprise me that if in the future portfolio will be a requirement from grade k-12. What better way to track and collect information and provides a well rounded perspective.
You also commented that blogs are supposed to be informal, but after all the research and reading blogs can be classified as whatever the intention of the author is. The expectation of writing guidelines can be applied. It’s a perfect example of how to make a tool more specified for your need as a teacher.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Hi! My name is Ariel Flinn. I am working on my M.Ed. in Instructional Technology at Kennesaw State University. 

    Archives

    December 2014
    July 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    July 2013

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly